First Comment Doesn't Register Activity

[nahummadrid]

If WP Discussion settings are set to "Comment Author must have a previously approved comment" and NOT "An admin must always approve the comment", upon a new user's first comment being approved it does not get an activity item registered for that comment.

When that same user makes second comment and it goes through only then do the bp activity items begin to fire.

Can anyone confirm? This wasn't an issue having both settings checked.

looking at all the settings:
Allow people to post comment on new article (checked)
Comment author must fill out name and email (checked)
Users must be register and logged in to comment (unchecked)
An administrator must always approve the comment (unchecked)
Comment author must have a previously approved comment (checked)

using Multisite WP3/BP 1.26

[DJPaul]

Not tested but I believe we'll need to use the 'comment_hold_to_approve' action to capture these approved comments. See wp_transition_comment_status().

[johnjamesjacoby]

(In [3420]) Fixes #2684 (branch)

[johnjamesjacoby]

(In [3421]) Fixes #2684 (trunk)

[DJPaul]

I want to check if an comment marked as spam (i.e. by Akismet) would get through this; I'll report back :)

[pisanojm]

@djpaul @buddypressoverlords

Hey this ticket has been sitting here for two weeks without any further feedback and is holding up the release...are there any further patches coming to test?

[DJPaul]

It's not holding up release, but I think we're good to close this ticket.